More Pages: Highlands Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27


Short and Sweet
A Good Taste of RadcliffeOne must not judge the gothic novel with the same standards as any work with more literary merit. The plots are trite, the devices are overused, the language is overblown, and the characters are decididly one dimensional. However, this is what is so great about Radcliffe. All of her work is throughly entertaining, highly amusing to a modern reader, and a source of excellent new vocabulary.
"The Castles Of Athlin and Dunbayne" is no exception. It only differs from Radcliffe's other work in two aspects: it is short (slightly over 100 pages), and it is set in Britian, not mainland Europe. Although it is her first novel and does not achieve the same greatness as later works, such as "Udolpho", it is still worth reading. The story centers around Mary, a Scottish nobelwoman, and her love affair with the low-born, but ever honorable Allyn. It contains an astounding number of chases across dark moors, mysterious noises, escapes from dungones, and passionate exchanges of lover's vows for its small size. What makes the novel so amusing and enjoyable is Radcliffe's serious, fervent tone as she earnestly describes the contrived and trite situations in the novel.
I am quite a fan of Radcliffe and admire her greatly for the prescedent she set in the history of fiction. "The Castles of Athlin and Dunbayne" is an entertaing read and a wonderful example of the gothic novel.


Rubenesque HeroineIan Sinclair, loyal leader of the clan Sinclair could not bring himself to leave his underlings, no matter what edict the English king might declare. Having staged his death, he continues to lurk around his castle, trying his best to lead his clan at night from behind a ghostly mask. A servant possessed of the "sight" warns him that a woman with sapphire-colored eyes will either save or destroy the clan. Ian keeps wary watch on the lady sent to settle his estate and soon finds himself enthralled with the buxom girl, English though she is.
Can Myrtle be the blue-eyed lass of the prophecy, the one who holds the fate of the clan in her hands? Can Ian's devastating masculine charms sway Myrtle's decision and save the people from further suffering?
What worked for me:
I always love a braw man in a kilt, and Ian made a fine hero, but I actually enjoyed disliking the villains in this story more than I did rooting for the protagonists.
Size-wise Myrtle was a tall, sturdy, girl but very uncomfortable in her body thanks to growing up with petite, dainty stepsisters who declared her as being "too broad in the beam" to be attractive.
What didn't work for me:
I had trouble swallowing the plotline wherein Ian was simultaneously portraying his own "ghost" and a masked, simple-minded servant. It ought to have been humorous, but was so far out of the realm of plausibility I really felt it just damaged Myrtle's characterization. Instead of coming across as sweet and naively trusting she appeared more as a bit of a slow-top for not catching onto the ruse sooner.
Overall:
A solid read for fans of Highland romances if they can overlook the occasional extreme plotline.
Warning: There are some sexy scenes in this story.
If you liked "Highland Ecstasy" you might also enjoy "The Bride and the Beast", "The Accidental Bride", "The Last Days of a Rake", "Unmarriageable", "The Fire-Flower", "Suddenly You", or "Enchanting Pleasures".
A good read

No Sale
A story that gives you a warm fuzzy feeling--great story!!

its too drown out
Unique

A very disappointing bookThe book went into too many areas of the family that were not only unnecessary, but not for the younger reader. For instance, why did we need to hear about Protestant vs. Catholic issues in the classroom, as well as Sandy's parents financial condition, other than having to sacrifice to pay for lessons and a chanter. Although set in the 50' or 60's, the end was so syrupy that I couldn't stand it.
I read this myself , and upon finishing it, I threw it away, something I've never done before.
On being Sandy

Very Bad!!!
An Excellent History of the Breed Book

misleading title.
Ok for 1st time dog owners-lacking in depth explanations

the call of the highlands

Difficult notation; known for errors and omissions.

Scholars beware